new york city,sense of guilt,jukebox,conversation,engagement,ex-cop,confusion,priest,obsessive compulsive disorder (ocd),attraction,cynical,book editor,school teacher,socialite,catholic church,childhood friends,wedding band,aspiring writer,getting married,inspiring,engaged,wedding plans,doubts,sad story,mother daughter relationship,future in laws,gone for the weekend,bar,best friends,posh hotel,the plaza,wedding arrangements,lounge,gift registration,ex-partner